Mothershed-Bey-Bey v. Canik USA, LLC, et al.

United States District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma · April 3, 2026 · No. CIV-26-288-G

Summary

The court denied as moot two partial motions to dismiss because the plaintiff’s amended complaint superseded the original pleading. The court also denied as moot a motion for an extension of time filed by Academy Sports & Outdoors, Inc. and Academy, Ltd.

Court
United States District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma
Writing for the Court
Charles B. Goodwin
Jurisdiction
United States District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma
Decision date
April 3, 2026
Docket number
CIV-26-288-G
Procedural posture
Defendants filed partial motions to dismiss the claims in Plaintiff's original pleading. Plaintiff timely filed an amended complaint while the motions were pending.
Precedential value
unknown
Parties
Warees Malachi Mothershed-Bey-Bey v. Canik USA, LLC, Century Arms, Inc., Century International Arms, Inc., Academy Sports & Outdoors, Inc., Academy, Ltd.
Disposition
other

Topics

motions to dismisspleadingscivil procedure

Practice areas

civil procedureproduct liability

Questions Presented

  1. Whether the defendants' partial motions to dismiss the original pleading remained viable after Plaintiff filed a timely amended complaint.
  2. Whether the defendants' related motion for an extension of time should be denied as moot.

Holdings

  1. A timely filed amended complaint supersedes the original pleading and renders the original pleading of no legal effect; therefore, motions directed to the original pleading are moot.
  2. The defendants' motion for an extension of time was denied as moot.

Key quotations

Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint supersedes the original pleading and renders it of no legal effect.

Factual background

Plaintiff filed an initial pleading asserting claims against the defendants. Before the defendants' partial motions to dismiss were resolved, Plaintiff timely filed an amended complaint.

Procedural history

Defendants Canik USA, LLC, Century Arms, Inc., Century International Arms, Inc., Academy Sports & Outdoors, Inc., and Academy, Ltd. moved to dismiss portions of the original pleading. Plaintiff filed an amended complaint, and the court held that the amended complaint superseded the original pleading, rendering the pending partial motions to dismiss and a related motion for extension of time moot.

Court Document

Open PDF
Loading document…