Francisco Javier Rodriguez Borgio v. Lakeview Development I, LLC

No. 3D24-2302 (Fla. 3d DCA Sept. 17, 2025) · Florida Third District Court of Appeal · September 17, 2025 · No. No. 3D24-2302

Summary

The Third District Court of Appeal of Florida affirmed a final judgment in favor of Lakeview Development I, LLC, in a breach-of-real-estate-contract action. The court held that the closing documents controlled the parties’ intent and affirmed under de novo review.

Court
Florida Third District Court of Appeal
Writing for the Court
Emas; Miller; Lobree
Jurisdiction
Florida Third District Court of Appeal
Decision date
September 17, 2025
Docket number
No. 3D24-2302
Procedural posture
Appeal from a final judgment in favor of Lakeview Development I, LLC, in an action for breach of a real estate contract.
Standard of review
De novo review
Precedential value
Published opinion
Parties
Michell Roxana Castellanos, Francisco Javier Rodriguez Borgio, 5630 Pine Tree Drive, LLC v. Lakeview Development I, LLC
Disposition
affirmed

Topics

breach of contractcontract interpretationreal estatestandard of reviewappellate procedure

Practice areas

ContractsReal estate

Questions Presented

  1. Whether the circuit court properly entered final judgment for breach of a real estate contract based on the written closing documents.
  2. Whether the closing documents had to be construed as written as the best evidence of the parties' intent.

Holdings

  1. Closing documents must be construed as written because they are the best evidence of the parties' intent.
  2. The final judgment in favor of Lakeview Development I, LLC, for breach of the real estate contract was affirmed.

Key quotations

we are required to construe [] [closing] documents as written, since they are the best evidence of the parties’ intent. (at 2)

Factual background

The appeal arose from a dispute concerning a real estate contract and the parties' closing documents. The circuit court entered final judgment in favor of Lakeview Development I, LLC for breach of that contract. On appeal, the appellants challenged the judgment, and the district court resolved the challenge by construing the closing documents according to their written terms.

Procedural history

The appellants appealed a final judgment entered by the Circuit Court for Miami-Dade County in favor of Lakeview Development I, LLC. The Third District Court of Appeal reviewed the matter de novo and affirmed.

Court Document

Open PDF
Loading document…