Chapman v. ADT LLC

Chapman v. ADT LLC · United States District Court, Northern District of Texas, Dallas Division · June 9, 2025 · No. 3:22-cv-02188

Summary

This document is a magistrate judge's findings, conclusions, and recommendation regarding a defendant's agreed motion to refer the case to a magistrate judge for mediation. The magistrate judge notes that the parties have engaged in extensive prior litigation across state and federal courts, including pending Fifth Circuit appeals and active state court proceedings on remand. Consequently, the magistrate judge recommends vacating the prior referral order and denying the motion for mediation, concluding that the matter is not an appropriate candidate for federal settlement conferences at this time.

Court
United States District Court, Northern District of Texas, Dallas Division
Writing for the Court
David L. Horan
Jurisdiction
United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas
Decision date
June 9, 2025
Docket number
3:22-cv-02188
Procedural posture
Defendant ADT LLC filed an Agreed Motion for Referral to Magistrate Judge to Conduct Mediation; the district court granted the motion and referred the case to a magistrate; the magistrate now recommends vacating that order.
Precedential value
nonprecedential
Disposition
other

Topics

mediationcivil procedureappellate procedure

Practice areas

civil procedure

Questions Presented

  1. Whether the district court should vacate its order referring the case to a magistrate judge for mediation.

Key quotations

Failure to do so will bar that party from appealing the findings and conclusions that the district court accepts or adopts, except upon the grounds of plain error.

Factual background

Chapman sued ADT LLC alleging employment discrimination. The district court dismissed the federal claims and referred the case to a magistrate for mediation. The parties have been involved in multiple related state and federal actions, and the Fifth Circuit is reviewing the dismissal.

Procedural history

The district court dismissed Chapman’s federal claims and referred the case to a magistrate for mediation. The Fifth Circuit affirmed the dismissal and is hearing a petition for rehearing. The magistrate judge issued a recommendation to vacate the referral order.

Court Document

Open PDF
Loading document…