In re the Estate of Henry A. Root, Deceased; Root et al. v. Blackwood, Executrix, et al., 120 Ind. App. 545

94 N.E.2d 489 (1950) · Court of Appeals of Indiana · October 17, 1950 · No. No. 18,005

Summary

The Indiana Court of Appeals held that corporate stock owned by a decedent is personal property whose title vests in the executor upon appointment, rather than directly in minor legatees. The executor could not avoid responsibility by allowing the corporation to continue operating under the direction of others without court authorization, and the case was reversed for a new trial concerning the executor's and trustee's reports and the exceptions thereto.

Holdings

  1. Corporate stock is personal property, and title to it vested in the executor upon the executor's appointment rather than immediately in the minor legatees.
  2. An executor cannot evade responsibility for estate assets by turning their administration over to a guardian or corporation without an order of court or legal authority.
  3. An executor who continues the decedent's business without a court order or authority in the will does so at personal risk, is liable for losses sustained, and must account to the estate for profits.

Questions Presented

  1. Whether title to the decedent's corporate stock vested in the executor or in the minor legatees upon the decedent's death.
  2. Whether the executor was responsible for administering and accounting for the corporate stock and could avoid liability by delegating control to the guardian or the corporation without court authority.
  3. Whether the reports of the executor and trustee should have been approved in light of the appellants' objections and exceptions.

Disposition

reversed_and_remanded

Cases Cited (11)

  • Citizens' Street Railway Co. v. Robbins, Administrator, 128 Ind. 449, 26 N.E. 116 (1891)(followed)
  • Bickel v. Bibler, 109 Ind. App. 7, 32 N.E.2d 127 (1941)(followed)
  • State ex rel. Department of Financial Institutions v. Kaufman, 218 Ind. 74, 30 N.E.2d 978 (1941)(followed)
  • Reed, Administrator v. Brown, 215 Ind. 417, 19 N.E.2d 1015 (1939)(distinguished)
  • Interstate Public Service Co. v. Weiss, Administrator, 208 Ind. 122, 193 N.E. 226 (1935)(followed)
  • Weyer, Administrator v. Second National Bank of Franklin, 57 Ind. 198 (1877)(followed)
  • Burwell v. Cawood, 2 How. 43 U.S. 559, 11 L.Ed. 378 (1844)(followed)
  • Smith v. Ayer, 101 U.S. 320, 25 L.Ed. 955 (1880)(followed)
  • Hart v. Anger, 38 La. Ann. 341 (1886)(followed)
  • Brasfield v. French, 59 Miss. 632 (1882)(followed)

Showing top 10 of 11.

Cited In (0)

No citing cases on record yet.

Court Document

Open PDF
Loading document…