Matter of Abdoch v. Abdoch

Abdoch, 2025 NY Slip Op 00746 (Appellate Division Fourth Judicial Department 2025) · Appellate Division, Fourth Judicial Department · February 7, 2025 · No. 59 CAF 24-00582

Summary

This Appellate Division, Fourth Department decision addresses an appeal by the Attorney for the Children regarding a Family Court order granting joint custody with designated zones of influence. The court held that children do not have full party status in custody matters and noted that neither parent appealed the underlying order. Consequently, the court dismissed the appeal to avoid forcing abandoned litigation upon the non-appealing parents.

Court
Appellate Division, Fourth Judicial Department
Writing for the Court
Whalen, P.J.; Curran; Greenwood; Delconte; Keane
Jurisdiction
New York
Decision date
February 7, 2025
Docket number
59 CAF 24-00582
Procedural posture
Appeal from an order of the Family Court, Monroe County, granting joint custody with designated zones of influence.
Precedential value
published
Parties
Alison Bates, Esq., Attorney for the Children v. Fonda D. Abdoch, Respondent-Respondent
Disposition
dismissed

Topics

family law procedureappellate procedurestandard of review

Practice areas

family law

Questions Presented

  1. Whether the Attorney for the Children has standing to appeal the Family Court order
  2. Whether children in a custody matter have full party status

Holdings

  1. The appeal is dismissed because the Attorney for the Children lacks standing; children do not have full party status and non‑appellant parents cannot appeal the order.

Key quotations

we find no basis in this record to depart from our prior case law holding that children in a custody matter do not have "full party status"

Factual background

The Family Court order granted joint custody of the children to the parties and designated zones of influence for decision‑making.

Procedural history

The Family Court entered an order on March 19, 2024, granting the parties joint custody of the children with zones of influence. The Attorney for the Children appealed the order.

Court Document

Open PDF
Loading document…