Indictor v. Indictor

2025 NY Slip Op 01615 · Appellate Division, Second Judicial Department · March 19, 2025 · No. Index No. 50551/12

Summary

This New York Appellate Division, Second Department decision addresses an appeal by Shimon L. Indictor from certain portions of a lower court's decision and order in a consolidated divorce and ancillary relief action. The court dismisses the appeal without costs, holding that the appealed portions do not constitute appealable decisions or orders under applicable civil practice rules. The court declines leave to appeal where the challenged rulings did not decide a motion made on notice.

Court
Appellate Division, Second Judicial Department
Writing for the Court
Miller, J.P.; Dowling; Wan; Golia, JJ.
Jurisdiction
New York
Decision date
March 19, 2025
Docket number
Index No. 50551/12
Procedural posture
Appeal from decision and order of Supreme Court, Richmond County
Precedential value
published
Parties
Shimon L. Indictor v. Helen Indictor
Disposition
dismissed

Topics

divorceappellate procedureappellate jurisdictionstandard of reviewfinal judgment rule

Practice areas

family law

Questions Presented

  1. Whether an appeal lies from a decision of the trial court
  2. Whether an order that does not decide a motion made on notice is appealable
  3. Whether leave to appeal should be granted

Holdings

  1. No appeal lies from a decision of the trial court
  2. The portion of the order does not decide a motion made on notice and leave to appeal is denied

Key quotations

ORDERED that the appeal is dismissed, without costs or disbursements. (at 1)

Factual background

The parties were married and filed a consolidated action for divorce and ancillary relief. The appellant, Shimon L. Indictor, appeared pro se. The trial court issued a decision and order on March 28, 2022.

Procedural history

Consolidated action for divorce and ancillary relief; appeal from portions of a decision and order dated March 28, 2022.

Court Document

Open PDF
Loading document…