STATE ex rel. OKLAHOMA BAR ASSOCIATION v. MENZER

2018 OK 46 (Okla. 2018) · Supreme Court of Oklahoma · June 4, 2018 · No. SCBD-6626

Summary

The Supreme Court of Oklahoma approved James Lloyd Menzer's resignation from the Oklahoma Bar Association while disciplinary proceedings and investigations were pending. The order struck his name from the Roll of Attorneys, barred reinstatement applications for five years, required compliance with disciplinary rules, and ordered reimbursement of $2,687.71 in costs.

Court
Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Writing for the Court
Chief Justice; All Justices
Jurisdiction
Oklahoma
Decision date
June 4, 2018
Docket number
SCBD-6626
Procedural posture
The Oklahoma Bar Association applied for approval of James Lloyd Menzer's resignation from the Oklahoma Bar Association while disciplinary proceedings and investigations were pending.
Precedential value
Published Supreme Court of Oklahoma order; the opinion states that it had not yet been released for publication and was subject to revision or withdrawal at the time of issuance.
Parties
State of Oklahoma, ex rel. Oklahoma Bar Association v. James Lloyd Menzer
Disposition
approved

Topics

appellate procedureremedies

Practice areas

legal ethicsattorney disciplineprofessional responsibility

Questions Presented

  1. Whether Menzer's resignation pending disciplinary proceedings complied with Rule 8.1 and should be approved.
  2. What conditions and consequences should accompany approval of the resignation, including removal from the Roll of Attorneys, the five-year restriction on reinstatement applications, compliance with Rule 9.1, and reimbursement of costs.

Holdings

  1. The resignation pending disciplinary proceedings complied with Rule 8.1 and was approved effective February 9, 2018.
  2. Upon approval, Menzer's name was ordered stricken from the Roll of Attorneys; he was barred from applying for reinstatement for five years from February 9, 2018; he was required to comply with Rule 9.1; and he was required to reimburse the Oklahoma Bar Association $2,687.71 in investigative costs.

Key quotations

It is therefore ORDERED that Complainant's application is approved and Respondent's resignation is accepted and approved effective February 9, 2018. (¶ 2)
It is further ORDERED that Respondent's name be stricken from the Roll of Attorneys and that he make no application for reinstatement to membership in the Oklahoma Bar Association prior to five years from February 9, 2018. (¶ 3)

Factual background

The Oklahoma Bar Association was investigating eight grievances alleging that Menzer failed to fulfill arrangements to provide legal services. Menzer voluntarily executed a resignation on February 9, 2018, acknowledged the allegations and their potential professional-conduct violations, and waived the right to contest them. He also agreed to comply with disciplinary rules, satisfy potential Client Security Fund obligations, and reimburse $2,687.71 in costs.

Procedural history

The Oklahoma Bar Association presented the Supreme Court of Oklahoma with Menzer's application and affidavit supporting resignation pending disciplinary proceedings under Rule 8.1. Menzer waived the right to contest the allegations, agreed to comply with applicable disciplinary conditions, reimburse Client Security Fund claims if paid, and reimburse the Bar Association's investigation costs. The Supreme Court approved the application and accepted the resignation effective February 9, 2018.

Court Document

Open PDF
Loading document…