Eric Lynn Baumgart v. The State of Texas

Baumgart · Texas Court of Criminal Appeals · December 18, 2015 · No. PD-1358-15; PD-1359-15; PD-1360-15; PD-1361-15

Summary

This document is a notice of incomplete records filed by Eric Lynn Baumgart in the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals in connection with four related criminal appeals. It identifies missing transcripts, indictments, motions, and other records, alleges that some trial-court records were purged, and asserts resulting due-process concerns. The appellant requests abatement for examination and reconstruction of the record, the opportunity to resubmit an appellate brief, and other appropriate relief.

Court
Texas Court of Criminal Appeals
Jurisdiction
Texas
Decision date
December 18, 2015
Docket number
PD-1358-15; PD-1359-15; PD-1360-15; PD-1361-15
Procedural posture
Appellant filed a notice asserting that the appellate and trial records in four consolidated criminal appeals were incomplete or missing and requested abatement, examination and reconstruction of the record, permission to resubmit an appellate brief, and other relief.
Precedential value
none
Parties
Eric Lynn Baumgart v. The State of Texas
Disposition
other

Topics

appellate procedurecriminal proceduredue processappellate jurisdiction

Practice areas

criminal appellate procedurecriminal procedureconstitutional law

Questions Presented

  1. Whether the appellate proceedings should be abated so the completeness and accuracy of the trial records could be examined and reconstructed.
  2. Whether an incomplete appellate record allegedly deprived Baumgart of due process and required an opportunity to submit a new appellate brief.

Factual background

Baumgart's criminal cases involved five separate charges that were consolidated into one trial. He alleged that portions of the clerk's and reporter's records were missing, including transcripts of pretrial and probable-cause proceedings, indictments, new-trial materials, and a capias. He further alleged that records associated with one acquittal case had been purged or were unavailable through the Harris County District Clerk's online system.

Procedural history

Five criminal charges were consolidated for trial in Harris County. Baumgart was acquitted in one case and pursued discretionary review in four others, which were appeals from the Fourteenth Court of Appeals under cause numbers 14-14-00307-CR through 14-14-00310-CR. The document is an appellant's notice filed in the Court of Criminal Appeals; it does not state a judicial ruling or disposition.

Court Document

Open PDF
Loading document…